16 January 2025

Why take the train?

Transport is the cause of around a third of global carbon emissions [1], so as we develop into a greener society, adopting more sustainable transportation will be imperative to our progress. Using greener transport – such as trains – is a clear step which individuals can take to benefit the environment, in a society where we often feel hopeless to make a noticeable contribution. As more individuals shift to using trains as their primary long distance travel method, corporations will take notice, investment will increase, and with money comes influence.

Transport is a key aspect of any modern civilization; it allows for a higher quality of life by providing superior education, economic and travel opportunities. There are a plethora of reasons why travelling by train is a great choice, whether you’re hopping between cities or taking a long-haul trip across Europe!

Photo: Piotr Guzik

Comfort

Due to the high cost of aviation [2], space is at a premium onboard commercial flights. This leads profit-driven airline companies to cram as many seats as possible into every plane. By comparison, train seats are wider, longer, and have better leg room. Furthermore, at any point in a train journey you can walk up and down the aisle (free from the shackles of the ‘fasten seatbelt’ sign) to stretch your legs, visit the bathroom or grab a snack.

Convenience/Connectivity

In many modern cities and towns, the station is situated in a central location. Upon leaving your train, you are immediately in the centre of activity from where you can start your visit. As trains run over land, they can make use of mobile networks to provide continual wi-fi connection. Whether you use the connection for entertainment throughout the journey or to squeeze out a bit more work on your commute, the added connectivity transforms dead-time into fruitful enjoyable or productive moments. Of course, wi-fi is available on many planes, but not if you commute or travel via car.

We all know the stress of arriving at the airport 4 hours ahead of the flight, queuing alongside hundreds of fellow sleep-deprived, worried passengers to nervously weigh-in your bags. This is followed by more queueing and getting poked and prodded by airport security who are bound to confiscate your favourite toothpaste. Then you still have to run to the gate just to make sure there’s no chance of missing the flight. However when you travel by train, if you miss the planned departure; just hop on the next train probably less than an hour later [3]. Over long-haul flights: sure, the time invested traversing the airport pays dividends, but if you are taking a short journey the more efficient boarding and disembarking process of rail travel can be the faster choice.

Clarity

You know what you’re getting when you buy a train ticket; there are no hidden costs, no fees for bringing extra luggage and no fees for sitting where you’d like to. Over land journeys are more stimulating and compelling, while the opportunity to see each part of the countryside between your destination and origin is enriching and provides context to your location.

Cost

Due to the outlandish base price of domestic flight, all parts of air travel are heavily government subsidised, so much so that every hour 4 million euros of potential airline taxes are ignored [4]. The aid is provided almost without discretion concerning aircraft CO2 emissions; governing bodies are missing out on an easy opportunity to require aircraft to meet certain green requirements to qualify for subsidies.
An example of these government subsidies is that aviation fuel is exempt from fuel duty, which is a levy placed on hydrocarbon fossil fuels [6] and it’s exempt from VAT. These are two of the larger subsidies provided which result in artificially low airline ticket prices and skew the balance against trains.

A comparison of different transport emissions, CO2 equivalent per kilometre travelled [8]

Carbon

Carbon emissions are mainly produced in the form of CO2 (carbon dioxide) which is a greenhouse gas alongside methane and nitrous oxide. Carbon dioxide is by far the most prevalent due to human activity producing so much of it. These gases warm the planet by reflecting light which has bounced off the Earth (and would otherwise carry on off into space) back towards the Earth. The increased temperatures from this process are a problem as they melt the snow, raise sea levels by melting ice, and cause drought by disrupting long-stable weather systems.

The average adult produces 4.7 tonnes of CO2 per year [6]. Flying from London to Rome and back produces 234kg of CO2 [7], which is 5% of your yearly emissions blown in the 5 hours of travel time.

Walking or cycling are the ideal low-carbon travel options, if you use a bike rather than a car your emissions will reduce by 75% [8] (although carbon emissions depend on what you eat). But when you need go further afield how do options compare?

Trains are the crème de la crème of long-distance carbon-efficient travel, as they reduce emissions by 80% when compared to cars and 86% when compared to planes. Even more impressively, taking the Eurostar from London to Paris or Brussels, when compared to flying, would cut your carbon emissions by 97%.

Importantly, when the number of passengers in a car increases, the carbon emissions per person decrease. So wherever possible you should car share on trips you take.

Countries in Europe and North America as well as China in Asia produce comparatively huge emissions. India, Africa, and South America (areas which will be among the most effected by rising worldwide temeratures) combined produce less than just Europe. In Europe our yearly emissions are higher than the worldwide average. To slow global warming the carbon we each produce must be halved. This is a complicated issue, further reading and comparisons can be made through the ‘Ourworldindata’ website [9].

Alpine Train Map

So what options are there to get to the Alps from around Europe? Well, thankfully David Cooper has designed an extremely handy map for SnowCarbon,
detailing the main rail lines from Italy, Spain, The UK, and Switzerland into the Alps or Pyrenees. It follows that countries with effective rail connections to these countries will also have easy access to the Alps by train, the author of this blog has travelled from Vienna to Morzine in one day by train and bus, as well as completing the journey from Edinburgh to the Alps by train via London, so it can be done. Starting at the eastern edge of the alps and traveling through to the west Alps was a beautiful journey with classic breathtaking Alpine views the whole way.

AlpinExpress Travel Guides

Montagne Verte have created a host of travel guides to help make crossing Paris easy, and show how to get from the train station to resort. These are practical guides with all the info needed for your journey. Find them here.

written by Ally Mayhew

Le Rail-Ski Map de snowcarbon.com, par David Cooper.

Sources

[1] ‘Transport and Mobility’, European Environment Agency, S Bakker, 12/06/2024

[2] ‘The Cost of Flying, What Airlines Have To Pay To Get you into the Air’, Simpleflying.com, J Hayward, L Ahlgren, A Mitchell, 22/11/2023

[3] ‘Train Timetable Paris-London’, sncf-connect.com, accessed: 22/07/2024

[4] ‘Price of Aviation’, transportenvironment.org, accessed: 24/07/2024

[5] ‘Fuel Duties’, obr.uk, Office for Budget Responsibility, 04/04/2024

[6] ‘The world’s top 1% of emitters produce over 1000 times more CO2 than the bottom 1%’, iea.org, 22/02/2024

[7] ‘Even Short Haul Flights Produce Huge Amounts of CO2 Figures Show’, theguardian.com, N Kommenda, 19/07/2019

[8] ‘Which Form of Transport has the Smallest Carbon Footprint?’, ourworldindata.org, H Ritchie, 30/08/2023

[9] ‘CO2 Emmisions, How much CO2 does the world emit? Which countries emit the most’ Ourworldindata.com, H Ritchie and M Roser, 15/01/2024

More useful resources from Montagne Verte: